Full Match Highlights (FIFA) | The Athletic Podcast — Tuchel’s Strategy Breakdown
There are football rivalries, and then there is Argentina versus England. The word “rivalry” isn’t sufficient to describe what it feels for these two countries to play against each other, on the pitch, in the stands, or in the respective nations. This is something older and darker and more personal than sport — a wound that history keeps reopening, dressed in blue and white on one side and red and white on the other. Wars have been fought between these two nations. Entire careers have been defined and destroyed by their meetings on a football pitch. Goals scored in these games have transcended sport and become cultural mythology. To call it the bitterest rivalry in football is not hyperbole. It is simply the truth.
And yet they hadn’t played each other in 21 years. Not since a friendly in 2005. Not in a World Cup knockout match since 1998. All of that accumulated history, compressed and held, waiting to detonate — and on Wednesday evening in Atlanta, it finally did.
The History That Made This Match
Before a ball was kicked in Atlanta, it was worth pausing to understand the weight of what was about to happen.
The 1986 World Cup semi-final at the Azteca produced two of the most famous goals in the tournament’s history, both authored by the same man, five minutes apart. First came the Hand of God — Maradona punching the ball into the net with his left fist, deceiving referee Ali Bin Nasser, then telling the world he had done it “a little with the head of Maradona and a little with the hand of God.” Four minutes later came the Foot of God — a solo run from the halfway line that beat five England players and Peter Shilton, a goal that FIFA’s fans would later vote the Goal of the Century. Argentina won 2-1 and went on to lift the trophy. That single game was the spark that ignited a fire between two nations that has been burning ever since. Maradona reached deity level status with that performance — D10S, a merging of “Dios” (God) and his shirt number, a word that fans printed on the back of his replica shirt and meant it with every sincerity. He could do no wrong in the eyes of his country for the rest of his career.
The 1998 World Cup in France added another chapter. Michael Owen, 18 years old and electric, announced himself to the world with a goal of breathtaking pace and composure. England led 2-1 before Argentina equalized in controversial circumstances and the game ended 2-2. Then came the defining moment: David Beckham, provoked by Diego Simeone — yes, that Simeone — kicked out and was sent off. Ten men. Penalties. David Batty and Paul Ince both missed. Argentina went through 4-3 on penalties. England went home. Another penalty kick shootout disappointment in their ledger. Beckham went home to death threats and an effigy burned in the streets. Watch the 1998 classic.
Four years later in Japan, at the 2002 World Cup, England finally had their revenge. In the Sapporo Dome, a deeply personal stage for Beckham, now captain, who had spent four years carrying the weight of that red card, England won 1-0 through a Beckham penalty just before half-time. Mauricio Pochettino — now a celebrated club manager — conceded the spot kick. Argentina, despite pressing furiously in the second half, could not find a way through David Seaman, who made a crucial point-blank save from Pochettino’s header at 77′. It was England’s first competitive victory over Argentina since 1966. Beckham converted the penalty with ice in his veins and celebrated with tears in his eyes. “It feels better than it did four years ago,” he told the BBC afterward. “It’s been a long four years.”
Now, in Atlanta, in 2026, these two nations met again in a World Cup semi-final. Both the most battle-tested teams of the final four. Argentina had won six games, five of them coming from behind, surviving the VAR controversy against Egypt and the sheer force of Egypt’s resistance that required three goals in thirteen minutes. England had beaten the United States, Belgium, Mexico with ten men against the altitude and atmosphere of the Azteca, and Norway in the quarter-finals, relying heavily on Harry Kane’s goals and the increasingly exceptional Jordan Pickford between the posts. Neither team had arrived here easily. Neither team was going to give this up without a war.
The First Half — Frenzy, Fury, and Precious Little Football
It started before a ball was kicked. The Argentine players sang their national anthem with the full-throated ferocity of men going into actual battle. Forty thousand blue-and-white shirts in the stands responded. The noise inside Atlanta Stadium was extraordinary — not the polite appreciation of neutrals watching a spectacle, but the raw, visceral roar of partisans with everything at stake. You could hear the chants of Argentina, Argentina from outside the stadium.
And then the game matched the atmosphere, blow for blow, elbow for elbow.
Within two minutes, Jude Bellingham was caught in the face by Leandro Paredes’ elbow. In the seventh minute, Giuliano Simeone — about whom more shortly — fouled Elliot Anderson to give England a free kick. At the 13-minute mark, Anderson and Fernández were at it again, and they looked ready to come to blows, with Morgan Rogers and Paredes joining in. Tuchel remonstrated furiously on the touchline. No cards. By the time the first hydration break arrived, the two squads had combined for eight fouls and zero official shots on goal — a statistic that tells you everything about the tone of the opening minutes..
At half-time the scoreboard read: nineteen fouls, two yellow cards, zero shots on target — almost certainly the first World Cup semi-final since records began with no first-half shots on goal, and the first game since 1966 without a shot on target in an entire half. The only genuine sight of goal came at 38′, when Enzo Fernández shaped a free kick that tested Emiliano Martínez. Elliot Anderson received his yellow card at 38′ for a robust challenge on Messi. Lisandro Martínez was booked at 42′ for cynically hauling back Rogers.
Into the middle of all this combustion stepped a name that rang with historical resonance: Giuliano Simeone. Diego’s son. Playing only his 71st minute of football in the entire tournament, Scaloni inserted him — apparently not for his technical gifts, though they are considerable, but for precisely what he demonstrated in those opening exchanges: the chip-off-the-old-block fighting spirit that seems to flow in the Simeone bloodline. Diego Sr., of course, was the man who wound up Beckham in 1998 and was central to England’s most painful World Cup night. Junior picked up the baton with relish, involved in numerous flashpoints, driving Argentina forward physically and psychologically. Both Simeones — Diego as a player and coach, Giuliano now — represent the ethos of the Argentine pibe in its purest form: real skill married to fighting spirit, gamesmanship, trickery, and a total refusal to be intimidated. Maradona embodied the same quality. This quality, transmitted across generations, is part of what makes Argentina Argentina.
The Second Half — Dickens in Reverse
Dickens, albeit inverted, comes to mind here. It was the worst of halves and the best of halves. If the first half was all about physicality, intimidation, and standing your ground (give no quarter take no quarter), the second half, by contrast, was all about magnificent football. England daring to take the lead and then daring Argentina to take it back.
Argentina came out for the second half with an immediate change of gear. Julián Álvarez, getting the better of Djed Spence, fired twice at Pickford in rapid succession early in the second period — the first blocked at the near post, the second deflected into the side netting. Then, at 49′, Jude Bellingham appeared to obstruct Messi in the box — bodies colliding, no call, replays suggesting England got away with one.
And then, at 55′, England scored — and the entire complexion of the game changed.
Lisandro Martínez acrobatically cleared but only as far as Declan Rice, who picked out Morgan Rogers to swing in a delightful cross that was swept home by Gordon — arriving at the back post and guiding the ball past Emiliano Martínez with his first career World Cup goal. 1-0 England. And then Thomas Tuchel made a decision that will be debated for years.
Tuchel’s Double-Decker Bus — and Why It Failed
The Athletic Podcast discusses this in detail
England parked the bus. Not just any bus — a double-decker (note references to this exact wording in the podcast above).. The entire team dropped deep, surrendered possession, and invited Argentina to come at them. What worked against Mexico — barely, with ten men, on the day Bellingham scored twice in two minutes — was now deployed against a different animal entirely. You do not give a footballing genius 35 minutes to decode your defensive strategy. You do not invite Messi to probe and probe and probe until he finds the answer. This was not caution. This was abdication. At 72′, Tuchel substituted Anthony Gordon — the goalscorer — for Ezri Konsa, a centre-back, adding defensive cover and draining what little attacking threat England had retained. The message was clear: hold what we have. Contain them. Dare them to score.
Argentina responded by throwing everything forward.
At 58′, Giuliano Simeone broke clear with a chance to equalize, arriving on goal alone — before Djed Spence delivered one of the tackles of the tournament, a perfectly timed slide that dispossessed him without a hint of foul. A goal-saving intervention that deserved far more credit than it received in the noise of the following minutes.
At 68′, Pickford produced a save of the highest order. Messi whipped a cross into the area and Nico González got his head to it from the centre of the box — point-blank, certain goal. Pickford got down sharply and palmed it away with one hand. Breathtaking.
At 76′, the post intervened on England’s behalf. Alexis Mac Allister met Rodrigo De Paul’s peach of a cross — a genuine gem of a delivery — and threw himself at it, thumping a header that crashed off the inside of the left post with Pickford rooted to the spot. At that moment Argentina deserved to be level. They were not. The post held. The scoreline held.
At 84′, Pickford produced another reflex save — this time from distance — tipping a Fernández drive over the crossbar. (These two saves matched in the two against Mexico and it appeared, for a minute, that England would hold, that their hot goalkeeper in full flow, a man channeling every save into the belief that this was England’s night, was was about to wipe that sixty years of pain away.
They weren’t.
Messi — Left Foot, Right Foot, Both Feet on History
The equalizer came at 85′. Fernández, who had seen that shot tipped over, did not panic. He set himself twenty yards out at the top of the 18 yard box. Argentina took the corner short to Messi, who swung around to his left, and sent a perfect pass to Enzo, who bent a superb finish around the crowd and into the far side of the net. Pickford, who had been brilliant up to that point, was just positioned fractionally wrong. Argentina had their tenth goal after the 75th minute in this World Cup. The stands erupted. England’s resistance, built on Pickford’s heroics and the posts’ charity, had cracked.
And then, at 90+2′, Messi crossed with his right foot. Lautaro Martínez, who had scored the Copa América winner in 2024, met it at the far post and headed it home. England’s World Cup dreams were buried. Messi had assisted both goals — the first with his left foot to Fernández, the second with his right to Lautaro.
The brilliance of that moment cannot be understated. Having utilized his left foot the majority of the match (and tournament), Messi did the equivalent of a basketball cross-over. After collecting a loose ball, he dribbled to his left as customary before a wicked change of direction to his right beat two England defenders before putting in his cross.
The goal, it must be stated, did not come without significant controversy. Should Messi have been ruled to have committed an accidental foul when he stepped on Spence’s foot trying to collect the loose ball, thus giving him an advantage at the key point where he dribbled to his right ? Should the resulting goal had been disallowed after a review of the play, akin to how Egypt’s goal was after a similar stepping of the foot foul from an Egyptian defender ? This point will be hotly debated for years to come. Was this Messi’s equivalent pibe move like Maradona in 1986; using a little chicanery to gain an advantage ?
I am of the opinion that this was and it wasn’t.
It was accidental and he got away with it as the referee didn’t call it and it wasn’t reviewed by VAR (just like Maradona). Why it wasn’t reviewed by VAR is another point entirely and the subject of another debate altogether, not withstanding FIFA’s official VAR reviews that determined the contact did not meet the threshold for a “clear and obvious error”.
But it wasn’t in the sense that Messi didn’t plan to do this, it just happened. (Maradona did for sure put his hand up there on purpose and just didn’t think he would really get away with it.)
A Team of Destiny
Argentina have now scored nine goals in the final fifteen minutes of games at this World Cup. They have come from behind in game after game — against Cape Verde, against Egypt, now against England. They are indefatigable. They are relentless. They are the comeback kings.
Coach Lionel Scaloni said it perfectly after the final whistle: “I think that this team plays the best when we are facing a difficult situation, with adversity. We had a challenging game, a challenging situation. There was blood in the water, and we went for it.”
The reason for all of this is clear. It has been clear since the tournament began. Argentina are a team of destiny because they are led by their second D10S. Not the hand of God this time. Not the foot of God. Just the left foot and the right foot of the greatest player who has ever lived, still performing miracles at 39, still dragging his country toward immortality, still reducing the entirety of English football to heartbreak in the final minutes of a World Cup semi-final.
Diego would have smiled.
PKs:
Argentina’s xG was 1.84 from 15 attempts. England’s was 0.53 from five. The numbers, as they always do in this tournament, told the truth about who the better team was.
Argentina face Spain in the final on Sunday in New Jersey. Messi vs Lamine Yamal. The man who held the baby, against the baby. The living legend, against the game’s next great prince. It is, as it has been all tournament, almost too good to be true.
Great article on Messi’s dribbling prowess:
https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/1880554/2020/08/07/lionel-messi-barcelona-la-liga-champions-league/
















